Article published in Edutopia.org, written by Jonathan Ketchell
Teaching media literacy can help high school students develop critical thinking skills while questioning what they see online.
As an educator who assists colleagues in teaching media literacy, I offer this lesson designed for high school students.
I show students a video that evokes an emotional response (see here) , especially when the video reaches its climax, the man saving the dog from the train. It's catchy, it's on TikTok, and the students love it. I have their attention.
Then I ask them if it is true or false, asking them to pay closer attention before I play it again. Claims are made, shouted from all sides of the classroom. Engagement and emotions are high. We check the comments on the video; many do not question its authenticity, commenting instead on the heroism of the man who saved the dog.
I ask the students to look more closely. The sharp-eyed will notice that the long shadow of the train on the bloated figure of the man lying relieved on the ground at the end should not be there. It is indeed a fake video.
That’s the easy part. It gets harder when I ask students why they think this fake content was created. The excited students are suddenly more subdued, their facial expressions telling me they’re thinking. They’re thinking collectively – there’s no right or wrong claim here at this point.
IS IT ILLEGAL TO BE OVERWEIGHT IN JAPAN?
Then I showed them the title of another video (see here). It's shocking, it's captivating, it makes you want to click and watch. Can this really be true? I ask for a quick show of hands to see if they want to watch the video. A majority says yes.
We watch together and then return to the title. Is it illegal to be overweight in Japan? The video doesn't suggest that, but I ask them to look up more information online. They do a good job, finding both reputable and unreliable sources, concluding as a group that the title is misleading. No, it's not illegal (see here) , but citizens in Japan from the ages of 40 to 74 must undergo annual weight exams.
Someone wrote this headline – what was their motivation for writing a misleading headline? “Because they want people to click on it,” one student exclaims. I urge them to go further, thinking in parallel about the motivations of the person who created the fake video we saw earlier.
"Because they want to make money."
I smile.
THE “WHY” QUESTION IN CRITICAL THINKING
Learning is (too) often a check-box experience. We have a series of objectives, rubrics, and deadlines to meet. See a fake piece of material? Check! Pointing out a misleading headline? Check! Verifying claims and checking sources? Check! These are all “technical” skills we need to learn, but what about why?
By cultivating why, students are developing their critical thinking, taking a stand, shaking up the status quo. We aim to provide them with the tools to question why social media apps are so addictive in the first place, why many web apps are – on the surface – free, why misleading headlines – clickbait – enhance our online experience.
Going further into the reasoning exposes a deeper understanding of how information spreads online. Why are online stories usually negative? Why are there bots creating and sharing content? It touches on seemingly unrelated elements – from human psychology to the data-driven model of internet advertising, from our instinct to be drawn to sensational headlines to our tendency to keep moving aimlessly. Yet they all fit into one puzzle.
Puzzle Pieces: Back in the classroom. With the help of an AI (Artificial Intelligence) chatbot, we imagine a breaking news story of a protest in a major city along with clashes between protesters and police. In groups, students are assigned puzzle pieces. One group is asked to write clickbait headlines; another is asked to create viral hoax posts on social media. Some look at creating fake accounts on various social media; others are assigned to imagine how left- and right-wing media outlets would portray the event. A final group creates fake AI-powered images of the event using one of the many tools now available for this.
The ability to explain is a key component of critical thinking, and the class listens as groups later not only present their results but also show the process and steps they took to arrive at their final result. Each is followed by a feedback session. From day one, I have tried to encourage open discussion, argumentation, and self-reflection, and these moments are key to this, with students taking the lead in offering observations as well as suggestions for improvement. Explaining how they came up with this or that is essential.
Learning how to think critically involves the ability to understand how these puzzle pieces fit together, so we draw a mind map on the board and connect the dots. Students are beginning to understand that disinformation is much more than just detecting a hoax.
Tomorrow's students will undoubtedly grow up in a network that will be radically different from this one, but regardless of technology, their ability to think critically will push them to understand, question, and challenge.
The question "Why" will be as important then as it is now.